Every season I look forward to the premiere of
American Horror Story. I'm usually disappointed... I feel like Ryan Murphy and his shows are a bit like Lucy and that football. Just as I'm excited for a touchdown, Murphy yanks that football away leaving me disappointed. It's not that Murphy doesn't create some incredible TV, he is brilliant at bringing concept to the screen and creating riveting first seasons. Sustaining quality however, is usually the issue. Murphy does well when he puts his focus on one season and one concept as he did with last years
Feud.
McDermott and Peters on set for
Apocalypse
I loved the first three seasons of AMS,
Coven, and especially
Murder House and
Asylum were my favorites. I love the characters and cast (Evan Peters in particular) and the story driven horror each story and setting created. Re-watching a few episodes of
Murder House recently reminded me how slowly and thoughtfully the story was unveiled with the violence a way to drive it forward.
McDermott in
Murder House
By the time
Freak Show aired, it felt the writers and producers were relying more on gratuitous violence and shock more than real terror from the circumstance created by story. I expect violence from AHS, I have no issue with it. The mass shooting at the end of
Freak Show however seemed a manipulative and easy way to ensure the season ended with a bang. It also undid all of the good work that led up to it.
There has been a mass shooting in almost every season of AHS, and the cruelty and torture elements were off the charts last season in
Cult. So much so, I stopped watching after about the third episode. AHS always blended a bit of comedy and wit, along with fascinating characters and great writing. Evan Peters acted his ass off, but the show itself was to me, unwatchable.
But... again this season I am heading back to give kicking that football a chance. I am (was) excited about the merge of
Murder House and
Coven and revisiting old characters and places I enjoyed in previous seasons. The title
Apocalypse , and the preview that I saw however, tells me the show is more than just a group of interesting witches visiting a hot guy in a fetish leather suit....
Peters in
Asylum
I am happy Peters is back, along with old favorites Dylan McDermott, Connie Britton and Jessica Lange are back but I am still wary. I'm tempering my expectations and time will tell whether this season will be a touchdown, (like almost every first season of a Murphy show) or a foul, (Popular season 2 anyone?) only time will tell.
Peters in
Coven